There's lots of philosophy videos to watch around the internet.
Saturday, June 27, 2009
Sunday, June 21, 2009
Iran: Legitimacy of Government, Consent and Revolution
Morally speaking, what are the citizens of a nation-state permitted to do when faced with an illegitimate government; a government that rules without the consent of the people? And what are the citizens permitted to do in terms of violence when the government is violently repressing them?
These are, of course, difficult questions. And you won't find an answer here. But the video below is inspiring.
The reform-agenda protesters face off with government forces and the people make the military turn and run. Watch all the way to the end.
To follow what's going on in Iran Andrew Sullivan's blog at the Atlantic Monthly is a good place to start. The Lede at Nytimes.com is deep into covering it. And there's the always well-informed Juan Cole.
These are, of course, difficult questions. And you won't find an answer here. But the video below is inspiring.
The reform-agenda protesters face off with government forces and the people make the military turn and run. Watch all the way to the end.
To follow what's going on in Iran Andrew Sullivan's blog at the Atlantic Monthly is a good place to start. The Lede at Nytimes.com is deep into covering it. And there's the always well-informed Juan Cole.
Monday, June 15, 2009
A New Bloggingheads.tv Video
Josh Greene and Josh Knobe discuss the philosophy and psychology of moral judgments at Bloggingheads.tv.
Tuesday, June 9, 2009
Does Studying Ethics Make You More Ethical?
The short answer is no.
Maybe explicit reflection crowds out other forms of moral responsiveness that are even better; or maybe reflection on philosophical examples eviscerates the intuitions on which we must depend; or maybe moral reflection is mostly just self-serving rationalization, at which ethicists are particularly talented.
Wednesday, May 27, 2009
The News and Observer, our local paper here at the Parr Center for Ethics, published an opinion piece on torture by Mark Bowden.
It seems his position is that torture should not be made legal, although sometimes it may be justified to torture.
He says torture should be illegal because it's heinous and to legalize it would remove us from "ethical purity." However...
Bowden is saying that it should remain illegal, although on some rare occasions a moral person would break the law and justifiably conduct torture.
Making it illegal...
So that's his position.
But he goes on to suggest that if he were among the "investigators" of those who tortured KSM and Zubaydah he'd be sympathetic with their motivation.
Unfortunately, there is reason to believe that the torture we are talking about was conducted not in any kind of ticking time bomb scenario. But rather it was used to find a link between al Qaeda and Iraq. A link we now know did not exist.
Lawrence Wilkerson, republican, retired Army colonel, and former chief of staff for Colin Powel, wrote in the Washington Note:
CNN reports on it here. From CNN:
More from CNN:
It seems his position is that torture should not be made legal, although sometimes it may be justified to torture.
The use of any coercive tactics against prisoners ought to expose those responsible to prosecution...
He says torture should be illegal because it's heinous and to legalize it would remove us from "ethical purity." However...
... few fair-minded people would weigh that ethical purity more heavily than preventing further attacks like those that killed thousands in September 2001.
The real damage done by Bush administration torture policies was the effort to codify coercion.
... all forms of torture, broadly defined, ought to be banned. What does such a ban mean? It means that anyone who gets rough with a prisoner is crossing the line and placing himself at risk. This, history makes clear, is the only way to curb the universal tendency of men to abuse those over whom they wield complete control.
Bowden is saying that it should remain illegal, although on some rare occasions a moral person would break the law and justifiably conduct torture.
Making it illegal...
does not mean that there can be no circumstance in which torture is justified, at least to those who would not adhere blindly to principle. Life presents moral dilemmas, and combat in particular produces them. To obtain life-saving intelligence when no alternative means are at hand, a moral person might reluctantly accept the responsibility for crossing that line. Those who investigate his actions later can determine whether they were justified, but the moral person accepts that he or she may suffer for making that choice.
So that's his position.
But he goes on to suggest that if he were among the "investigators" of those who tortured KSM and Zubaydah he'd be sympathetic with their motivation.
I [...] respect the decision in 2002 to take whatever steps were necessary to pry information from Sheikh Muhammad and Zubaydah. An inquiry may reveal that their questioners were motivated primarily by a desire to inflict suffering and that they achieved nothing, but I doubt it. I believe they were urgently motivated to thwart attacks on al-Qaeda's drawing boards, and probably did so.
Unfortunately, there is reason to believe that the torture we are talking about was conducted not in any kind of ticking time bomb scenario. But rather it was used to find a link between al Qaeda and Iraq. A link we now know did not exist.
Lawrence Wilkerson, republican, retired Army colonel, and former chief of staff for Colin Powel, wrote in the Washington Note:
"Its principal priority for intelligence was not aimed at preempting another terrorist attack on the U.S. but discovering a smoking gun linking Iraq and al Qaeda,"
CNN reports on it here. From CNN:
Wilkerson wrote that in one case, the CIA told Cheney's office that a prisoner under its interrogation program was now "compliant," meaning agents recommended the use of "alternative" techniques should stop.
At that point, "The VP's office ordered them to continue the enhanced methods," Wilkerson wrote.
"The detainee had not revealed any al Qaeda-Baghdad contacts yet. This ceased only after Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi, under waterboarding in Egypt, 'revealed' such contacts."
More from CNN:
"This is my opinion," Maj. Paul Burney told the inspector-general's office. "Even though they were giving information and some of it was useful, while we were there a large part of the time we were focused on trying to establish a link between aI Qaeda and Iraq and we were not being successful in establishing a link between aI Qaeda and Iraq. The more frustrated people got in not being able to establish this link ... there was more and more pressure to resort to measures that might produce more immediate results."
Burney's account was included in a Senate Armed Services Committee report released in April.
NPR interviews Duke Professor Dan Ariely on Money, Morality and Decision-Making
Professor Ariely's new book about human fallibility in decision-making is called "Predictably Irrational."
NPR has made a transcript of the interview available and an mp3 file so you can listen to it online.
NPR has made a transcript of the interview available and an mp3 file so you can listen to it online.
NewsHour economics correspondent Paul Solman recently sat down with behavioral economist Dan Ariely, who studies irrationality in economic decision making, to discuss why people cheat, the media's influence on markets and whether the public needs to see remorse on Wall Street.
Ariely: "In the media, there's this slogan that says, 'If it bleeds, it leads,' with the idea that if something is emotionally capturing, then we want to emphasize that. And because of this there's a bias both in the media and in ourselves as human beings to overemphasize things that are emotionally grabbing." [...]
Ariely: "So if you think to yourself: What's more important? To have a report about one unfortunate individual who lost their job and has very difficult life circumstances, or something that helps us understand more generally what is going on in AIG, how is the bailout going, what is the future of this company?" [...]
Ariely: "So it's the news feeding our psychology of caring more about emotional things, and because of that much of the news is not really that educational and informative in terms of helping us understand what is going on, instead of just kind of tapping our emotion over and over and over. And I think because of that people also get more fearful. If all the news is focusing on these terrible pieces of information about how frightening this is, and this is, and gloom here, and gloom there, we're going to be much more fearful."
Saturday, May 23, 2009
Which Class of Society in America Gives Most Generously to Charity?

America's poor donate more, in percentage terms, than higher-income groups do, surveys of charitable giving show. What's more, their generosity declines less in hard times than the generosity of richer givers does.
"The lowest-income fifth (of the population) always give at more than their capacity," said Virginia Hodgkinson, former vice president for research at Independent Sector, a Washington-based association of major nonprofit agencies. "The next two-fifths give at capacity, and those above that are capable of giving two or three times more than they give."
Indeed, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics' latest survey of consumer expenditure found that the poorest fifth of America's households contributed an average of 4.3 percent of their incomes to charitable organizations in 2007. The richest fifth gave at less than half that rate, 2.1 percent. [...]
The working poor, disproportionate numbers of which are recent immigrants, are America's most generous group, according to Arthur Brooks, the author of the book "Who Really Cares," an analysis of U.S. generosity. [...]
"When you have just a little, you're thankful for what you have," Pastor Coletta Jones said, "but with every step you take up the ladder of success, the money clouds your mind and gets you into a state of never being satisfied."
Brooks offered this statistic as supportive evidence: Fifty-eight percent of noncontributors with above-median incomes say they don't have enough money to give any away. [...]
What makes poor people's generosity even more impressive is that their giving generally isn't tax-deductible, because they don't earn enough to justify itemizing their charitable tax deductions. In effect, giving a dollar to charity costs poor people a dollar while it costs deduction itemizers 65 cents.
Read the story here.
Thursday, May 14, 2009
Parr Center Fellow Pens Op-Ed at the News & Observer Protesting Mukasey Commencement Speech
Joseph E. Kennedy, an associate professor of law at UNC School of Law and a fellow here at the Parr Center for Ethics wrote a column explaining his decision to wear a orange arm band to protest former U.S. Attorney General Michael Mukasey's commencement speech at the Law School.
Read the whole column here.
In the Bybee memo of August 2002, a memorandum that Mukasey characterizes as a mistake, the head of the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel essentially defined torture as an interrogation technique that causes the equivalent of organ failure. He got that definition not from any legal authority defining torture but from a definition of "severe pain" found in an obscure medical benefits statute.
Such reasoning would receive an F grade if offered by a first-year law student. When offered by the head of the elite Office of Legal Counsel it must be seen for what it was: a lie about the meaning of the law, not a mistake.
Read the whole column here.
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
More on the Science of Morality
There have been lots of articles reporting recent work in the science of moral judgments and most of them use a catchy headline based on an intuition that finding out about why we act morally will mean the end of morality. Lots of people have that intuition apparently, but is the claim true? Please talk about it in the comments.
Anyway, here's another article on the science of morality and its title is "So Much For Morality". But of course nothing in the article suggests that the research reported therein spells the end of morality.
The article ought to have been headlined with a remark about temporal distance or abstraction in relation to moral judgments, right?
Anyway, here's another article on the science of morality and its title is "So Much For Morality". But of course nothing in the article suggests that the research reported therein spells the end of morality.
When we think of temporally distant events, we think more abstractly, which makes us focus on superordinate aspects and the main purport of the event. But if we think of events that are close to us in time, we think more concretely, which means that subordinate, peripheral aspects take on more importance. For example, if we imagine that we will be asked to donate blood in the future, what dominates is the superordinate moral value of helping other people, but if the time perspective is telescoped, concrete subordinate selfish motives take over, such as the fact that it will be unpleasant to be stuck by a needle.
The article ought to have been headlined with a remark about temporal distance or abstraction in relation to moral judgments, right?
Friday, May 8, 2009
Eyewitness to the Dalai Lama Talking about Religion and Morality
A pair of bloggers at Huffingtonpost have reported on their first hand experience with the Dalai Lama in Costa Rica. They were impressed by this religious man's insistence that morality can exist without a divine power. Popular culture seems to have it that morality depends on God's laws. But in academic philosophy and in the great thinkers of the past we read in philosophy departments the possibility of secular morality is basic.
Read their whole post here
He said that only a very small percentage of people, despite their membership in one kind of religion or other, are actually taking their religion very seriously. Most so-called "religious" people are only very superficially involved with the particular faith, in which they happen to have been brought up. To that he added something even more daring and maybe even shocking to many of his academic but still nominally Catholic listeners, when saying, "most people are really only money-worshippers," implying that their religious pretensions are, at rock bottom, only hypocritical.
... in addressing his student audience at the University of Costa Rica, the Dalai Lama affirmed specifically that ethics and morality need not be based on religion or belief in "God." He frankly admitted that, in this respect, he did have a strong disagreement with the Pope, in their recent, private meeting. The latter insisted, of course, that morality had to be based on religious faith. In contrast, the Dalai Lama declared that ethics and morality can arise simply out of recognition of our mutual interdependency, leading in turn to such secular virtues as respect, caring, and compassion for others.
Read their whole post here
Tuesday, May 5, 2009
"Big Finance is Prowling the Limbic System"
N.E. Marsden, an "educator specializing in media research" who blogs at the Huffingtonpost has written a post about recent brain science and how banking has changed since the 80s. The financial sector used to facilitate investment in companies, like buying "a piece of the rock," she says. But now money is made on transactions more and more, and by being able to predict how people will react to certain situations, because the market's reaction sets price.
Gone are the days when investors bought "a piece of the rock" and kept the certificates locked in bank vaults. Today, the fast money bets on moment-to-moment fluctuations, and traders profit on both the dips and spikes. In this casino-like atmosphere, profit often derives from winning transactions, not brick and mortar valuation and growth.
Bloomberg reported in 2004 that Arrowstreet, a $4.4 billion investment firm, had developed quantitative models to "identify and exploit" incidents when investors 1) overreact to news, 2) follow the herd, or 3) fail to account for new information.
Now, Big Finance is prowling the limbic system, a primitive slab of gray matter linked to emotions like pleasure, greed, fear, and cravings -- which begs the question, why?
The 2008 bestseller, Buyology provides an explanation:"Finance and economic research has hit the wall," explains Andrew Lo, who runs AlphaSimplex Group, a Cambridge, Massachusetts hedge fund firm. "We need to get inside the brain to understand why people make decisions."
Neuromarketing guru Martin Lindstrom, the author of Buyology, goes a step further:...economic modeling is based on the premise that people behave in predictably rational ways. But...what's beginning to show up in the fledgling world of brain scanning is the enormous influence our emotions have on every decision we make.
Monday, April 27, 2009
Today's Universities are as Outmoded as Detroit
New York Times op-ed contributor, Mark C. Taylor, pens a column on the state of the University.
He gives in particular one example:
Read the whole column here.
GRADUATE education is the Detroit of higher learning. Most graduate programs in American universities produce a product for which there is no market (candidates for teaching positions that do not exist) and develop skills for which there is diminishing demand (research in subfields within subfields and publication in journals read by no one other than a few like-minded colleagues), all at a rapidly rising cost (sometimes well over $100,000 in student loans).
In other words, young people enroll in graduate programs, work hard for subsistence pay and assume huge debt burdens, all because of the illusory promise of faculty appointments. But their economical presence, coupled with the intransigence of tenure, ensures that there will always be too many candidates for too few openings.
He gives in particular one example:
The division-of-labor model of separate departments is obsolete and must be replaced with a curriculum structured like a web or complex adaptive network. Responsible teaching and scholarship must become cross-disciplinary and cross-cultural.
Just a few weeks ago, I attended a meeting of political scientists who had gathered to discuss why international relations theory had never considered the role of religion in society. Given the state of the world today, this is a significant oversight.
Read the whole column here.
Link to Executive Summary of the Levin Report
The Levin report opens with this epitaph:
Here's the link: Executive Summary of the Senate Armed Services Committee on Detainee Treatment also known as the Levin Report.
What sets us apart from our enemies in this fight... is how we behave. In everything we do, we must observe the standards and values that dictate that we treat noncombatants and detainees with dignity and respect. While we are warriors, we are also human beings. - General David Petraeus
Here's the link: Executive Summary of the Senate Armed Services Committee on Detainee Treatment also known as the Levin Report.
The abuse of detainees in U.S. custody cannot simply be attributed to the actions of "a few bad apples" acting on their own. The fact is that senior officials in the United States government solicited information on how to use aggressive techniques, redefined the law to create the appearance of their legality, and authorized their use against detainees.
Sunday, April 26, 2009
Reckoning with America's Practice of Torture
In Frank Rich's column this weekend, he suggests that the recently declassified "Bybee memos" fill in holes in the timeline of events after 9/11 such that denial is no longer possible.
What motivated the enhanced interrogations?
Indeed, it has been said by people who would know that torture is not useful for intelligence, it's useful in creating false confessions, which, of course, have their own uses.
Read the complete column here.
Still, it’s not Bybee’s perverted lawyering and pornographic amorality that make his memo worthy of special attention. It merits a closer look because it actually does add something new — and, even after all we’ve heard, something shocking — to the five-year-old torture narrative. When placed in full context, it’s the kind of smoking gun that might free us from the myths and denial that prevent us from reckoning with this ugly chapter in our history.
[Abu Zubaydah's] most valuable contribution was to finger Khalid Shaikh Mohammed as the 9/11 mastermind. But, as Jane Mayer wrote in her book “The Dark Side,” even that contribution may have been old news: according to the 9/11 commission, the C.I.A. had already learned about Mohammed during the summer of 2001.
As soon as Bybee gave the green light, torture followed: Zubaydah was waterboarded at least 83 times in August 2002, according to another of the newly released memos.
What motivated the enhanced interrogations?
Maj. Paul Burney, a United States Army psychiatrist assigned to interrogations in Guantánamo Bay that summer of 2002, told Army investigators of another White House imperative: “A large part of the time we were focused on trying to establish a link between Al Qaeda and Iraq and we were not being successful.” As higher-ups got more “frustrated” at the inability to prove this connection, the major said, “there was more and more pressure to resort to measures” that might produce that intelligence.
In other words, the ticking time bomb was not another potential Qaeda attack on America but the Bush administration’s ticking timetable for selling a war in Iraq; it wanted to pressure Congress to pass a war resolution before the 2002 midterm elections.
Indeed, it has been said by people who would know that torture is not useful for intelligence, it's useful in creating false confessions, which, of course, have their own uses.
Five years after the Abu Ghraib revelations, we must acknowledge that our government methodically authorized torture and lied about it. But we also must contemplate the possibility that it did so not just out of a sincere, if criminally misguided, desire to “protect” us but also to promote an unnecessary and catastrophic war. Instead of saving us from “another 9/11,” torture was a tool in the campaign to falsify and exploit 9/11 so that fearful Americans would be bamboozled into a mission that had nothing to do with Al Qaeda.
Read the complete column here.
Saturday, April 25, 2009
Experimental Philosophy and Acting Voluntarily
The relevant passage from Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics:
"Done under compulsion" means that the cause is external, the agent or patient contributing nothing towards it; as, for instance, if he were carried some-where by a whirlwind or by men whom he could not resist.
But there is some question about acts done in order to avoid a greater evil, or to obtain some noble end; e.g. if a tyrant were to order you to do something disgraceful, having your parents or children in his power, who were to live if you did it, but to die if you did not — it is a matter of dispute whether such acts are involuntary or voluntary.
Throwing a cargo overboard in a storm is a some- what analogous case. No one voluntarily throws away his property if nothing is to come of it, but any sensible person would do so to save the life of himself and the crew.
From the translation of F.H. Peters
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
Torture and the Truth
Andrew Sullivan at the Atlantic makes an interesting connection between the Western Enlightenment's devotion to finding the truth and the prohibition on torture.
Read his post here.
The Western anathema on torture began as a way to ensure the survival of truth. And that is the root of the West's entire legal and constitutional system. Remove a secure way to discover the truth - or create a system that can manufacture it or render it indistinguishable from lies - and the entire system unravels. That's why in the West suspects are innocent before being found guilty; and that's why in the West even those captured in wartime have long been accorded protection from forced confessions. Because it creates a world where truth is always the last priority and power is always the first.
Read his post here.
Thursday, April 16, 2009
Education and Opportunity
A very interesting column by Nicholas Kristof about I.Q. in the New York Times today.
Professor Nisbett strongly advocates intensive early childhood education because of its proven ability to raise I.Q. and improve long-term outcomes. The Milwaukee Project, for example, took African-American children considered at risk for mental retardation and assigned them randomly either to a control group that received no help or to a group that enjoyed intensive day care and education from 6 months of age until they left to enter first grade.
By age 5, the children in the program averaged an I.Q. of 110, compared with 83 for children in the control group. Even years later in adolescence, those children were still 10 points ahead in I.Q.
Tuesday, April 14, 2009
Twitter Will Not Morally Corrupt You
The blog at Discover Magazine confirms my suspicion about the article I mentioned earlier in the week which said Twitter could undermine your morality.
What Immordino-Yang says there may be too vague for assessment, but for some kinds of moral cognition time and reflection is not necessary, as the recent empirical moral psychology of Professor Jonathan Haidt and others has shown.
Quick! Grab the latest scientific study that may have something remotely to do with Twitter! Run it with a “Twitter Will Destroy Humanity!” headline! With a graphic by Hieronymus Bosch!
Somehow, this finding has grave implications for Twitter, since, according to Immordino-Yang:For some kinds of thought, especially moral decision-making about other people’s social and psychological situations, we need to allow for adequate time and reflection.
Uhh, seriously? So does that mean pre-Internet humanity, with its countless hours of reflection, was also blessed with impeccable morality?
What Immordino-Yang says there may be too vague for assessment, but for some kinds of moral cognition time and reflection is not necessary, as the recent empirical moral psychology of Professor Jonathan Haidt and others has shown.
Posner on Morality and the Downturn

Here is the best one-paragraph summary of the depression/recession that I've seen.
It's by Richard Posner in an interview with Dwyer Gunn at the Freakonomics blog at the New York Times Online. I'll quote it in full.
Q: What caused the financial crisis? Was it the government’s fault?
A: The government was the facilitator of the crisis, in the following sense. Banking (broadly defined to include all financial intermediation) is inherently risky because it involves borrowing most of one’s capital and then lending it, and the only way to create a spread that will pay the bank’s expenses and provide a return to its owners is to take more risk lending than borrowing — for example, borrowing short (short-term interest rates are low, because the lender has little risk and great liquidity) and lending long (so the lender has greater risk and less liquidity). The riskiness of banking can be reduced by regulation. But as a result of a deregulation movement that began in the 1970’s, the industry was largely deregulated by 2000. Then the Federal Reserve mistakenly pushed down and kept down interest rates, which led to a housing bubble (because houses are bought with debt) and in turn to risky mortgage lending (because mortgages are long term and there is a nontrivial risk of default); and when the bubble burst, it carried the banking industry down with it. The effect on the nonfinancial economy was magnified by the fact that Americans had little in the way of precautionary savings built up. Their savings were concentrated in risky assets like houses and common stock. When the value of those savings fell steeply, people’s savings were inadequate, so they curtailed their personal consumption expenditures, precipitating a fall in production and sales, a rise in unemployment (which made the still-employed want to save even more of their income, lest they lose their jobs too), and, in short, the downward spiral we’re still in.
That's pretty good, I think. Clear, concise and doesn't take too many shortcuts that rely on special knowledge. But then he goes on to say something pretty enlightening about the moral outrage that's been directed at the "excessively risky behavior" of some in the financial community. It's a problem of regulation, not greed. And the regulation is consistent with Adam Smith.
Part of maximizing profits, however, is taking a certain risk of bankruptcy; it does not pay for a firm to reduce that cost to zero. Banking occupies a strategic role in the economy because of the importance of credit to economic activity; borrowing to spend increases consumption — it is how we shift consumption from future to present....
Moreover, banking is the main instrument by which the Federal Reserve creates money, and by doing so reduces interest rates (provided inflation is not anticipated; for if it is, long-term interest rates will rise), which in turn spurs economic activity. By buying government bonds, it pours cash into banks, both directly, when it buys the bonds from banks, and indirectly, when it buys the bonds from private owners but the owners deposit the cash they receive from the purchase into their bank accounts.
When banks start to hoard cash because their solvency is impaired, the money they receive from the Federal Reserve’s purchasing activity does not spread into the rest of the economy. That is why a cascade of bank bankruptcies is far more serious than a cascade of, say, airline bankruptcies. But a rational businessman does not, indeed cannot afford to, consider the cost of bankruptcy to the economy as a whole as distinct from the cost to his firm. So the rational banker will take more risk than is optimal from an economy-wide standpoint. That is the logic of profit maximization, as explained long ago by Adam Smith: the businessman cares about his costs and his revenues, but not about the costs and revenues incurred or received elsewhere in the economy. He is not an altruist. The responsibility for preventing the collapse of the banking system is the government’s, and it has been shirked, with extremely serious consequences.
That is quite an indictment of the regulatory bodies. Does it let the bankers off too easily? Or does he make a good point about risk and limiting risk? For one, this seems to only apply to risk taking and not to the big bonuses which were also a source of moral outrage.
Photo from Wikipedia
Monday, April 13, 2009
Twitter and Facebook could harm moral values, scientists warn
I found it rather unconvincing.
What do you think?
Using Twitter and Facebook could harm moral values, as they don't allow time for compassion or admiration, scientists have warned.
What do you think?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)